Registration is FREE and takes seconds to complete!
Club-tC Members Receive:
» Advertisement Free Browsing
» Access to all tC Tech Articles
» Ability to post questions and comments
» Use of private message system
» Ability to share images
» Their own personal profile page
» More tC information then anywhere else
Sign Up Now!

Strut Bars vs. Sway Bar

Discussion in 'Suspension & Brakes' started by punk2m1d, Dec 11, 2008.

  1. Offline

    punk2m1d New Member

    Member Since:
    Apr 8, 2008
    Location:
    2008 Scion tC
    I have a trd sway bar. If I get a strut bar up front will it be over kill or counter productive? Do I need to lift the car to release the tension on the springs before I put the strut bar on?
  2. Offline

    MR.310 New Member

    Member Since:
    Oct 7, 2008
    Location:
    2007 SCION TC
    A strut bar connects the top of the two front shock towers, or the top of the two rear shock towers. It controls chassis flex, and allows the suspension to do the job properly. It doesn't really DO anything except make your chassis stiffer (doesn't affect the movement of your wheels on any axis).


    A sway bar actually limits body roll. It is like a giant spring connecting one side of the car to the other. Actually it is a circular rod going from side to side. At each end there is a turn in the rod, then a further length of rod, and the attachment point. The distance from the attachment point to the bend is the lever arm.

    If your car leans to the left in a corner, the sway bar tries to also pull the right side of the car down.

    It limits body roll, allowing your tires to stay at a more effective angle to the road.

    i got this from another form kuz i really wanted to know to. :inv:
  3. Offline

    MR.310 New Member

    Member Since:
    Oct 7, 2008
    Location:
    2007 SCION TC
    so depending on how u drive i think its not a bad idea to get both, unless i read it completly wrong

    :dog:
  4. Offline

    punk2m1d New Member

    Member Since:
    Apr 8, 2008
    Location:
    2008 Scion tC
    Thank you. I understand the difference between the two, I just didn't know if having upgrades on front and back would be bad. I dunno, dumb. I did hear that to get the most out of the strut bar you have to lift the car and release all tension from the springs before your put the strut bar on. Is this true?
  5. Offline

    Redneck4csa Premium Member

    Member Since:
    Oct 2, 2008
    Location:
    07 Scion tC

    How could having upgrades on the front and back hurt? It would only make it better. The tighter the suspension, the better it will handle in the twisties.
  6. Offline
    • Staff / Moderator

    navylife59 Super Moderator

    Member Since:
    Mar 22, 2006
    Location:
    2005 Scion Tc
    It is all about balance. With a good set of lowering springs, the weak point in the suspension is the rear swaybar. Chassis stiffening only serves to tighten up the entire platform. This falls inline with what the others have stated. You will be suprised how much tires fit into this equation.
  7. Offline

    JMSTC New Member

    Member Since:
    Oct 25, 2008
    Location:
    2007 TC
    So what about lifting the car? Is it necessary? If I don't have any suspension upgrades yet would it be beneficial to do the front and back at the same, and or what should be done first if I can only afford one at a time?
  8. Offline
    • Staff / Moderator

    navylife59 Super Moderator

    Member Since:
    Mar 22, 2006
    Location:
    2005 Scion Tc
    What do you mean by "lifting the car"? Most people do the strutbar first as it is rather easy to install, looks good, and realtively inexpensive. However, you will not notice (perceived) much improvement until other suspension components are upgraded like the rear swaybar and/or springs.

    The rear swaybar can be upgraded without changing the front swaybar or even adding a strutbar. This upgrade will make the most change in corner transition for the price. Installation is not too difficult but requires the car to elevated either by jack or lift. Suggest that you pull the rear tires off for better access. This also makes the perfect time to paint your calipers/rotors! Dezod sells upgraded end links for the rear swaybar that are adjustable.

    You can peruse our 'How-to' articles for step-by-step installation instructions.
    http://www.club-tc.com/forums/suspension/
  9. Offline

    punk2m1d New Member

    Member Since:
    Apr 8, 2008
    Location:
    2008 Scion tC
    Okay. I have heard. That if you want maximum performance from a strut bar, you should first lift the car off of the ground. This way the springs are relaxed and have as little tension on them as possible. This is just what I have heard. My question is, is that fact or crap?
  10. Offline

    Redneck4csa Premium Member

    Member Since:
    Oct 2, 2008
    Location:
    07 Scion tC
    It would be my thought that if you do that and set the car back on the wheels, you would get a binding on the strut bar. You'd be putting alot of unwanted stress on the bar itself.
  11. Offline
    • Staff / Moderator

    navylife59 Super Moderator

    Member Since:
    Mar 22, 2006
    Location:
    2005 Scion Tc
    There may just be a little truth in that fiction. First, it sounds as if they are talking about the sway bar and about putting pretension on the bar to make it stiffer. There is simply no truth in that as you have to change the position of the end-link connection on the bar, resize/shape the bar, or shorten the end-link itself to make it stiffer. What that are alluding to is actually the lower control arm and rear link bars on RWD axles. If you were to remove these units then replace them, you have to torque the mounting bolts while the arm/link is under load (weight of the vehicle). To do so with the vehicle weight off on jacks) them, then the rubber bushings would be under pretension. Then when you lower the vehicle to the ground these bushings would be placed in a bind and cause poor suspension motion. As for the strutbar, yor not going to be able to move the shock towers witha floor jack.

    This is an exerpt from the Scion tC maintenance manual.

    STABILIZE SUSPENSION
    (a) Install the front tire.
    Torque: 103 N*m (1,050 kgf*cm, 76 ft.*lbf)
    (b) Lower the vehicle and bounce it several times to
    stabilize the front suspension.
    14. FULLY TIGHTEN FRONT SUSPENSION NO. 1
    LOWER ARM SUB-ASSEMBLY LH
    (a) Fully tighten the 2 bolts.
    Torque: 137 N*m (1,400 kgf*cm, 101 ft.*lbf)
    NOTICE:
    • Keep the nut from rotating while tightening
    the rear side bolt.
    • Make the tire condition contact ground with a
    4 post lift.

  12. Offline

    punk2m1d New Member

    Member Since:
    Apr 8, 2008
    Location:
    2008 Scion tC
    Thank you. I will not worry about lifting the car then. This site is filled with nice people willing to help. For someone who loves their car and wants to make it better, these forums for sure help.
  13. Offline
    • Staff / Moderator

    navylife59 Super Moderator

    Member Since:
    Mar 22, 2006
    Location:
    2005 Scion Tc
    Thank you. We may be a bit slow at times to answer, but those answers will be most helpful. It is sad to say that other forums (not just autos) are filled with fluff (bickering). That is what drew me and many others here a long time ago.

    What is it that you want to improve or change on your suspension? We should be able to hook you up with the info that you need to make a good game plan towards that goal.
  14. Offline

    punk2m1d New Member

    Member Since:
    Apr 8, 2008
    Location:
    2008 Scion tC
    I have the trd rear sway (love it), an injen axle back, and a fujit cai. This is my grocery getter as well as my fun car. I want it to stand out, and have more power than expected.

    I'd like to drop it about 1.5" - 2" and put the front strut brace on. The debate of struts/springs vs. coilovers is never ending. What do you guys suggest? I wouldn't need the ability to change the heigth. I'd drop it and leave it there.
  15. Offline
    • Staff / Moderator

    navylife59 Super Moderator

    Member Since:
    Mar 22, 2006
    Location:
    2005 Scion Tc
    Hotchkis Stage I TVS system. Since you already have the rear strut, you will have to order the springs and swaybar separately. Suggest that you get the adjustable rear camber links as anything lowerin drop than the TRD springs goes beyond the adjustment capabilities of the stock camber bolts. The fronts really don't matter on Hotchkis springs. Just have the Dealership align to the TRD springs specifications and your golden. The springs have not settled and dead even tire wear after 40K miles since install. 90% of the pics of my car are with those springs. Not too low and ride quality good. Handling is superb.

    Installing the front swaybar will be more of a challenge, but can be DIY. Not required but easier done on a lift and with pneumatic tools. A quality torque wrench is required though. Suggest that you also get the Energy Suspension Master Bushing Set while your at it. This will be time consuming, but if you wanting a super responsive ride, then these are what you need. Next upgrade will be tires and/or wheels.
  16. Offline

    TcforLIFE New Member

    Member Since:
    Jan 31, 2009
    ....shouldnt you get tires, and wheels first? :/ lol

    cause im pretty sure thats what your supposed to do, cause thats where you will get MOST traction. and then the suspention. well, actually
    idk lol
  17. Offline
    • Staff / Moderator

    navylife59 Super Moderator

    Member Since:
    Mar 22, 2006
    Location:
    2005 Scion Tc
    Yes you could, but you paid for those stockers so why not use them? The tires are fairly descent. My Bridgestone Potenzas actually did fairly well in the traction department, especially, in the rain. What the tC needs up front is suspension tweaks. If the suspension is sloppy and you have sticky tires, you will get more traction. The traction won't be as good as it can be and the tires will wear out faster than normal. Spend alot of money on tire upgrades and you would hope that you will get full life out of them.
  18. Offline

    punk2m1d New Member

    Member Since:
    Apr 8, 2008
    Location:
    2008 Scion tC
    Which strut bars have worked best for you guys? I imagine there's not many differences with this mod. I could be wrong. Tanabae is the cheapest one I've found, but it does look a little flimsy compaired to others I've checked out.
  19. Offline

    Redneck4csa Premium Member

    Member Since:
    Oct 2, 2008
    Location:
    07 Scion tC
    I will be going with DC SPORTS when I decide to buy one...
  20. Offline
    • Staff / Moderator

    navylife59 Super Moderator

    Member Since:
    Mar 22, 2006
    Location:
    2005 Scion Tc
    Be aware that some strutbars don't mount properly. The Greddy bar also covers the spark plugs making them difficult to remove. I know the Hotchkis and the TRD fit very well.
    Greddy Strut Bar Mount - Lft.jpg

Share This Page

Users found this page by searching for:

  1. strut bar vs sway bar

    ,
  2. strut bars vs sway bars

    ,
  3. struct bar vs sway bar

    ,
  4. strut vs sway bars